Why Listing Rentals on the MLS Is a Waste of Time (and Money)

Thinking of using the Multiple Listing Service (MLS) to lease your rental property? You might want to think again.

While some real estate agents swear by it, the MLS is often a poor fit for landlords—especially small or Do It Yourself owners. Here’s why using the MLS for rentals is usually a costly, complicated, and inefficient move.

1. It’s Expensive for What You Get

Listing a rental on the MLS can cost $300–$500+, especially if you need to go through an agent or brokerage. Compare that to sites like Zillow, Apartments.com, or Facebook Marketplace, which are often free or offer affordable paid options.

Example:
If your rental is listed at $1,800/month and you spend $500 to post it on the MLS, that’s nearly 30% of your first month's rent—just to get a listing live. And that doesn't guarantee a tenant.

2. It Adds Unnecessary Hassle

Unlike rental-focused platforms where you can create a listing in minutes, the MLS usually requires a licensed agent to post on your behalf. That means more emails, contracts, and coordination—not to mention slower updates if you want to tweak pricing or photos.

If you're managing your own rental, this just adds a middle layer that slows everything down.

3. It’s Not Built for Rentals

The MLS was made for sales, not leases. It lacks features renters are used to, like filters for lease terms, pet policies, or 3D tours. Most MLS users are looking to buy homes, not rent them—so your listing gets buried or ignored.

Example:
A renter searching Zillow can easily find a pet-friendly apartment under $2,000 with in-unit laundry. On the MLS? Good luck filtering for that.

4. You’re Reaching the Same Audience—Just Paying More

Most MLS listings are syndicated to rental sites like Zillow and Trulia anyway. So if you list directly on Zillow, you’re already reaching that audience—without the markup.

In short: MLS doesn’t open doors to new renters. It just makes you pay more to get through the same ones.

5. Renters Don’t Use It

Unlike buyers and real estate agents, everyday renters don’t search the MLS directly. They go where the listings are easiest to browse: Zillow, Apartments.com, HotPads, Craigslist, and Facebook Marketplace.

If your target tenant isn’t looking on the MLS, why should you be listing there?

The Bottom Line

The MLS is great—for buying and selling homes. But for rentals, it’s outdated, overpriced, and ineffective.

Save your money. Skip the MLS. List where the renters actually are.

Instead, focus on rental-first platforms designed for today’s renters. You’ll get better exposure, more qualified leads, and save hundreds of dollars in the process.

Unlock Your Property's Full Earning Potential

Ready to maximize your rental income? Submit an inquiry today and discover how Rental Price Pro's data-driven strategies can boost your property's profitability!